Case Study: Redesigning the Arkham Horror Playmat for a Better Player Experience
Why I redesigned the Arkham Horror playmat
I make playmats, and I read every review we get. The first version of our Arkham Horror playmat got plenty of kind words for its bright artwork and sturdy build, but one complaint kept coming back: card placement. One customer put it plainly. The mat had no room for their hand, and the layout felt restrictive because of it.
That feedback sent me back to the drawing board. I stripped out zones that weren't earning their space and opened up the layout so players could arrange things their own way. I made a second big change while I was at it. The original art was AI-generated, and I replaced it with commissioned pieces from professional artists. The mat has more personality now, and the money goes to real people who make art for a living.
The new version puts flexibility and comfort first, and it still looks great on the table.
Identifying the problem
The review was honest about the good and the bad:
- Strong visuals: The high-resolution artwork and bold colors added a lot to the theme.
- Quality and durability: The polyester blend surface gave a smooth feel that holds up over time.
- Layout limits: The card zones didn't match the player's usual setup, and there was nowhere to put their hand.
- A reason to come back: The customer said they would buy again if the layout improved, which told me people wanted a more usable mat.
Other feedback had pointed the same way. A mat that only suits one playstyle isn't doing its job, so the layout needed more breathing room.
The redesign: comfort and flexibility first
I wanted to fix the layout without losing the creeping dread that makes Arkham such a good game on a dark evening. Here is what changed.
1. No more fixed draw and discard zones
The original mat had marked spots for your draw and discard piles. Some players liked that. Plenty of others found that the fixed spots fought the way they already set up their games.
I removed those zones entirely. That opened up room for you to put your deck and discard pile wherever you want them, and the mat no longer tells you how to play.
2. Open space for your hand
The biggest complaint was the lack of room for cards in hand. A lot of players, especially the ones who plan a few turns ahead, like to keep their hand laid out on the table while they think. The old mat didn't allow for that, and it was frustrating.
The new design leaves open space on both sides, so you can set your hand down naturally whenever you're not playing a card. It's a small adjustment, but it makes a long scenario more comfortable and keeps your cards within reach while you focus on the game.
3. Built for left- and right-handed players
Hand dominance matters more than most people expect. Some players keep their cards on the left, and others keep them on the right.
With the restrictive zones gone, the redesigned mat has neutral open space on both sides. Lefties and righties can both get comfortable, which makes the mat friendlier for more people.
4. A cleaner layout
Instead of piling on labels and zones, I went minimal. The mat gives you a good-looking surface and trusts you to lay out the game in whatever way makes sense at your table.
5. Commissioned artwork in place of AI art
The first version used AI-generated art. I came to value original, hand-drawn work that tells a stronger story, and the updated mat now features commissioned artwork from professional artists. That change brings:
- A more personal, atmospheric take on the theme
- Real artistic expression that players notice at the table
- Paid work for the creative people who bring new ideas to tabletop accessories
I'm committed to artist-driven designs, and this change makes the mat feel much more at home in the Arkham Horror world.
Results and player impact
Taking out the rigid zones and adding open space for cards fixed the main usability problem. The polyester blend surface and the moody artwork stayed. The improved layout:
- Puts the player first, with no forced placements
- Works for different playstyles and for either dominant hand
- Lets players organize their cards the way they naturally would
- Gives players more reason to stick with the mat over the long haul, and to come back for another
- Replaces AI-generated images with commissioned illustrations from professional artists
What I took away from it
This redesign came straight from player feedback. Removing the extra zones and making room for your hand made the mat more intuitive and a lot more fun. The new art gives it a personality the old version never had.
For me, the lesson is that a good accessory has to look great and work well at the same time. Getting there also let me support independent artists, and that makes me proud. You can see the new mat alongside the rest of our Arkham Horror LCG playmats, which are unofficial accessories made by a fan of the game. If your group has a layout all its own, you can build a mat from scratch in Playmat Studio. I went through a similar process with another mat, and you can read about it in our Imperium playmat case study.